Will Pounder is feeling the heat for his girlfriend, Molly Little, on Christmas Eve. Trying to get Molly into the mood as well, Will begins feeling her up as they snuggle in bed. Molly puts him off, though, claiming that they have to be up early. That just leaves Will with blue balls and a sad outlook on what his marriage will be like.

As Will is sulking, he hears a noise in the living room. Sneaking downstairs, he sees Anna Claire Clouds dressed in a sexy Santa getup putting presents under the tree. When Anna glances over and sees Will, her lips curl into a smile as they tease each other back and forth.

Finally, Anna gets down to business and tells Will he's been good all year. It's her job to reward good boys, so he'll get three wishes. Will thinks about it and then says he wants to watch Molly and his ex girlfriend Alex Coal fuck. Sitting on the couch beside Will, Anna claims that it'll take lots of Christmas magic to get Molly in the mood, but it's the night for miracles after all.

Clapping her hands, Anna summons Alex first. Strutting into the room wearing some stunning lingerie, this girlfriend of Christmas past does her best to rile Will up right from the start. She shows herself off before settling next to Will to get nice and handsy with him. When Anna claps twice again, Molly makes a similar appearance, including some hot lingerie of her own. The ghost of Christmas present leans in and whispers in Alex's ear, saying something Will can't hear.

Anna isn't done yet. She announces that there's of course the girlfriend of Christmas future, which is Anna herself. Getting to her feet, she stands between the other two girls as they all get down to begin blowing Will's cock. Leaning back, Will takes it with a huge smile as the three girls share his dick so nicely. Eventually it's just Anna sucking as Molly and Alex make out and work each other out of their lingerie, just as Will wished.

As Anna climbs aboard to ride Will's hardon in cowgirl, Alex gets busy between Molly's thighs. She licks and sucks until Molly is a whimpering mess. Then the four come together with Will banging Alex in doggy and fingering Molly. Alex eats Anna out, ensuring that everyone is getting their kicks in the hottest possible way. Eventually Molly creates a double pussy stack with Anna so that Anna can finger Molly while Alex indulges in a double decker feast.

Molly gets the D next, with Anna stroking Molly's clit. Alex can easily make herself cozy riding Molly's tongue. They keep it up until Molly is squealing in delight, then switch things up one last time. Now it's Anna with Will between her thighs and Molly on her face. Will finally pulls out to nut on Anna's stomach, giving the girls a Christmas treat to share. Will tells Molly he wants her gone so Anna can move in, which is fine with Molly since she now plans to move in with Alex.