Damon Dice and Alyx Star have gotten together with Quinton James and Aubree Valentine for Thanksgiving. Aubree expects that it'll be another three and a half hours before dinner is ready. To pass the time, Alyx suggests that they should play a game.

After a bit of debate, the couples settle on Never Have I Ever so they can get to know each other better. They go to the living room, where they sit down on the couch. Aubree has been crushing hard on the oblivious Alyx, so she takes the opportunity to sit nice and close.

The game begins and gets raunchy quickly. It takes a bit of coaxing, but eventually Aubree gets Alyx to admit something dirty during the game: She has never touched a vagina that wasn't hers. Aubree asks if Alyx wants to fix that while sliding her hand up Alyx's thigh. When Alyx still hesitates, Aubree grabs her friend's hand and puts it right on her pussy.

With an invitation like that, Alyx isn't about to say no. She slides Aubree's underwear aside and slips her fingers up and down Aubree's slit. Even though Alyx tries to hide it, it's not hard to see how turned on she is. Aubree doubles down by announcing that never has she ever had friends she didn't swing with, which gives both Alyx and Damon pause.

When the other couple hesitates, Aubree does some more convincing. She leans forward to capture Alyx's lips in a deep kiss. Then she gets handsy, popping Alyx's luscious titties out of her dress so she can play with them. Alyx's hard nipples can't lie about how much she likes it.

Pulling back, Aubree instructs Alyx to go kiss Quinton. Meanwhile, Aubree locks lips with Damon. That only encourages Aubree and Quinton to keep on pushing. Aubree begins feeling up Damon's hardon while Quinton whips his out for Alyx to enjoy. Soon both girls are sucking each other's husband's cocks.

There's no point turning back now, so the foursome keeps it up. The guys get to indulge in some serious pussy eating, with Damon exploring Aubree's twat and Quinton tonguing Alyx. Then Aubree climbs on top of Damon's lap to ride him in reverse cowgirl while Quinton gets Alyx on her hands and knees to do her in doggy.

The girls switch up their positions, with Aubree laying down on the couch so Damon can bang her as she lays on her back. Looking up, Aubree can watch Alyx riding Quinton's hardon in cowgirl. They switch positions one last time, with Aubree taking it in doggy and Alyx on her back. That's all the guys can give; Quinton fills Alyx with a big creampie and Damon gives Aubree the same treatment, nutting inside her creamy fuck hole.